Playing Consultation
A pet project I was planning was a website for people to rate their local parks. Not exclusively for young people but also for parents - one of the things about moving to a new area is trying to find local places to take the kids so I thought it could be handy to map out play parks and allow people to add comments & photos etc.
I also considered the possibility of building something to allow people to add their own designs and suggestions for improvements - all of this is still at the ‘one day I’ll get round to it stage’ for now though!
I was interested then to see the Department for Schools, Children & Families new website ‘playspace’ and I’ve just had a bit of fun playing with it! (link here)
Its actually a consultation disguised as a game where you can design your own park, so not quite as exciting as I’d hoped, but as far as consultations go its pretty good.
There are a few flaws in terms of consultation - firstly that I’m probably not in the target age range (although I did play it with my 3 year old if that counts!), secondly the bit thats really interesting (building the park) can only be done after asking a series of questions for which you get ‘credits’ that you ca use to add items to your park. This is all ok - except that once all the questions have been answered a little character gets to ‘play’ on the park you designed - but once he’s been on all the stuff thats it! Of course Sam wanted him to keep playing and to build another park - but to do so you have to answer the same questions all over again so maybe there will be a few multiple entries in the consultation from enthusiastic play park builders!!
I think it would have been really good to have taken the concept just a bit further and allowed children to properly design their own parks and then to be able to submit their designs. The questions in the consultation seem a bit obvious to me and I’m not sure of the value they’ll provide but I’m sure it would have been very interesting to have seen what children & young people really want in their local play areas if the game could have been designed just a little differently.

I thought the question and reward was an interesting way of govt getting people to work through multiple questions which was good - but as you say - it then needs to go a little further….
Would have been good to see a MyAbodo (http://myabodo.com/) style option to embed the resulting park in a MySpace / Blog etc…
But overall this is really interesting progress for Government in terms of creative consultation… it will be interesting to see if they come up with a good creative way of feeding back to young people on what will change from their involvement…
I agree Tim - its good to see this kind of approach and good to see the potential to hopefully do even more similar stuff.
Probably something I should also have mentioned is that the building & drawing type stuff is something that both Ben (4yrs) & Sam (3yrs) can understand how to use and are both able to move stuff about etc. although they can’t yet read so of course couldn’t answer the questions on their own. But that does suggest potential to use this sort of thing to be able to get ideas & views from very young children - I know 11 Million have a similar application on their site but this was a bit too open (they just used it for doing random drawings & didn’t understand the palettes so well) - but I’m very interested in these kinds of applications - its also good for ideas for some of the stuff we’re planning with OnTheUp